Template:Rubrics/VxV

|Guardian Review|Overseer Review|Final Checks|Description| | --- | --- | --- | --- | ||||**Completeness** |[ ]||| The page includes every element required by the creator guidelines. |[ ]||| It includes the welcome text at the beginning, with the correct Psalm number. |[ ]||| It includes the category label at the bottom of the page, as well as the indication of the chapter/psalm number, e.g., 67. |[ ]||| It includes the correct sections: (1) a section for each verse, (2) a section for legends, (3) a section for the bibliography, (4) a section for footnotes. |[ ]||| Each verse includes the Hebrew text, the CBC text, the expanded paraphrase, and the phrase-level diagram. |[ ]||| It includes a complete bibliography in the bibliography section. Every secondary source cited in the page (standard reference works and translations excluded) has a complete bibliographic entry. |[ ]|[ ]|| It includes a thorough series of notes for the psalm as a whole, ideally with notes on each verse. |[ ]|[ ]|| It includes other visuals where relevant throughout the page (e.g., Venn diagrams, poetic features visuals, poetic structure visual, macrosyntax visual, etc.). ||||**Quality** |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The notes provide a thorough exegesis of the psalm. No important issues are left undiscussed. |[ ]|[ ]|| The notes are ordered according to [the principles given in the creator guidelines](https://psalms.scriptura.org/w/Verse-by-Verse_Notes#4._Organising_notes) (i.e., order of the text and scope). ||||**Engagement with secondary literature** |[ ]|[ ]|| Secondary sources are cited throughout the page, especially in the argument maps. |[ ]|[ ]|| The arguments of other scholars with whom we disagree are put forward in the strongest possible terms. |[ ]|[ ]|| No secondary source which is especially relevant to the discussion has been omitted. ||||**Clarity of language** |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The notes in the main text are clear and concise. |[ ]|[ ]|| Technical discussions are relegated to footnotes. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Language is not too technical so as to be inaccessible to [Sarah](https://psalms.scriptura.org/w/Personas). ||||**Formatting/Style** |[ ]||| Correct spelling and punctuation is used throughout. |[ ]||| Page is properly titled. |[ ]||| Page is properly structured. |[ ]|[ ]|| When a note discusses a particular word or phrase from the CBC, that word/phrase is bolded the first time it is mentioned in the note. |[ ]||| No other text on the page is bolded. |[ ]||| Sources are cited properly, both in the footnotes and in the bibliography. |[ ]||| Any extra visuals that have been included are appropriately sized and positioned.