Template:Rubrics/Synthesis

|Guardian Review|Overseer Review|Final Checks|Description| | --- | --- | --- | --- | ||||**Completeness** |[ ]||| Each element required by the creator guidelines has been included. |[ ]||| Prominence analysis (4-5 features) |[ ]||| Prominence summary heat map |[ ]||| Icon for the psalm |[ ]||| Title for the psalm |[ ]||| Purpose, content, message |[ ]||| Background ideas |[ ]||| Background situation |[ ]||| At-a-glance verse numbers and sections |[ ]||| Section headings |[ ]||| Section emotion labels |[ ]||| Section summaries |[ ]||| Section connections (where relevant) |[ ]||| Section icons ||||**Quality of analysis** |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Both title and icon are distinctive and memorable. Ideally, the title will use language from the psalm itself. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The features chosen for prominence analysis show clustering, contrast, and/or repetition. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The prominence summary heat map derives logically from the features presented. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The notes supporting prominence provide useful additional information/observations. |[ ]||| The 'purpose' is consistent with the Speech Act Analysis. |[ ]||| The 'purpose' has been narrowed to one over-arching main verb. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The 'content' accurately summarizes the main point(s) of the psalm. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The 'message' is consistent with the Story Behind, poetic features, and at-a-glance section headings/summaries. |[ ]||| The background ideas and situation are drawn from the Story Behind. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Sections are based on the Poetic Structure visual. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Connections are based on the Poetic Structure and/or Poetic Features visuals. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Section headings are concise (1-2 words where possible), accurate (outlining the story/flow of the poem), and memorable (e.g., relatable to real life and catchy, if possible, through contrast, alliteration, etc.). |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Section summaries are concise and accurately summarize the content of each section, using language directly from the psalm where possible. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Each icon captures something distinctive about each section. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The notes about each item provide a clear rationale for each decision. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The notes for purpose, content, message, title, and icon provide alternate options to be considered. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The visual, as a whole, captures what is most distinctive about the psalm in terms of structure and content (even if this requires the use of some unique visual elements not specified in the guidelines!). ||||**Clarity of language** |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Titles and headings are clear and concise. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| All summaries (including section summaries, purpose, content, and message) use language that is clear and natural. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| The At-a-Glance visual is not too busy. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Language is not too technical so as to be inaccessible to [Rinda](https://psalms.scriptura.org/w/Personas). |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Icons are not too difficult to interpret. ||||**Formatting/Style** |[ ]||| The visuals are based on the templates in MIRO and so use the correct font sizes, styles, and colors. |[ ]||| Icons are appropriately positioned. |[ ]||| The color of each icon corresponds to the color of the relevant section. |[ ]||| If the psalm has a superscription, it is formatted similarly to the superscription in the Ps. 19 example in the creator guidelines.