Template:Rubrics/Macrosyntax

From Psalms: Layer by Layer
Jump to: navigation, search

|Guardian Review|Overseer Review|Final Checks|Description| | --- | --- | --- | --- | ||||**Completeness** |[ ]||| Every element required by the creator guidelines is included. |[ ]||| Subordination is marked. |[ ]||| Coordination and scope, where applicable, is marked. |[ ]||| Vocatives are marked, and their function is discussed in the notes section. |[ ]||| Other discourse markers, and their semantic scope, where applicable, are indicated and discussed in the notes section. |[ ]||| Direct speech is boxed. |[ ]|[ ]|| All cases of marked topic, marked focus, frame setters and thetic sentences are correctly indicated in the visual and explained in notes section. |[ ]|[ ]|| The scope of an activated topic, if applicable, is indicated. |[ ]|[ ]|| Every other instance of non-default word order for purposes of poetic structure is explained in the notes. |[ ]|[ ]|| Discourse discontinuities are indicated and justified in notes section. |[ ]|[ ]|| Translation is expanded where relevant according to the information structure. ||||**Quality of analysis** |[ ]||| Clause divisions correspond with divisions in the grammatical diagram. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Any points of the analysis that are controversial and/or significant are thoroughly explained and defended in the notes section. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Arguments for preferred interpretations are cogent. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Discourse discontinuities are well-grounded in macrosyntactic evidence. ||||**Engagement with secondary literature** |[ ]|[ ]|| For areas of difficulty and debate, an effort was made to follow the discussion in the CG's appendix and engage with secondary sources (for example, Lunn [2006] and Khan & van der Merwe (2020) on word order; Di Giulio [2013] and Locatell [2017] on discourse markers and kî; Miller [2010] and Kim [2022] on vocative positions). ||||**Clarity of language** |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Prose notes are clear and concise. |[ ]|[ ]|[ ]| Language is not too technical so as to be inaccessible to [Sarah](https://psalms.scriptura.org/w/Personas). ||||**Formatting/Style** |[ ]|[ ]|| All colours, fonts, and shapes match those which are given in the template and creator guidelines.