Psalm 88/Notes/Grammar.V. 12.489918

From Psalms: Layer by Layer
Jump to: navigation, search
  • v. 12 Just like in v. 13, the interrogative particle הֲ spans over both parts of the disjunctive question. In fact, the question here is merely rhetoric and not disjunctive: "Double questions... need not always be mutually exclusive; frequently the disjunctive form serves (especially in poetic parallelism) merely to repeat the same question in different words, and thus to express it more emphatically... The second member may, therefore, just as well be connected by a simple וְ" (Gesenius §150h). We therefore assume an elided waw here, like the one explicit in v. 13. This waw is also attested in LXX and some Hebrew manuscripts.