The Syntax and Meaning of Ps 49:16: Difference between revisions

From Psalms: Layer by Layer
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(46 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 14: Line 14:
These translations indicate that there are two main difficulties in the interpretation of v. 16.
These translations indicate that there are two main difficulties in the interpretation of v. 16.


#One difficulty is related to the MT's punctuation of v. 16. The difficulty here is that in the second half of this verse (v. 16b), the MT places ''atnah'' after "Sheol". Some modern translations follow this punctuation, seeing v. 16a as a case of "enjambment", a device, whereby a poetic thought spills over across two or more lines without a pause. Others, however, ignore ''atnah'', rendering this verse as, "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol Will he surely snatch me".<ref>Dahood 1966, 301.</ref>  
#One difficulty is related to the line division and syntax of v. 16. Should the prepositional phrase "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) be grouped with the preceding clause/line or with the following? The MT places the major disjunctive accent ''atnach'' on the word "Sheol," thereby grouping "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) with the preceding clause/line. Some modern translations follow this punctuation. For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, for He will receive me" (NASB). Other interpreters, however, group "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) with the following clause/line, rendering this verse as, "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me".<ref>Dahood 1966, 301.</ref> The latter reading indicates that the psalm presupposes the idea of "assumption" (cf. Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10). 
#Another challenging point is the function of כי in v. 16b. Some read it as "for/because", thus subordinating v. 16b to v. 16a, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV). Some take it temporally, i.e., as "when" (e.g., JUB; WYC; etc.). Yet others take כי as the emphatic "surely", rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV).
#Another challenging point is the function of כִּי in v. 16b. Some read it as "for/because", thus subordinating v. 16b to v. 16a, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV). Some take it temporally, i.e., as "when" (e.g., JUB; WYC; etc.). Yet others take כִּי as the emphatic "surely," rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV).


=Argument Maps=
=Argument Maps=
==Line Division of v. 16==
==Line Division of v. 16==
===Following the MT===
==="...Sheol" belongs with first clause===
In the second half of this verse (v. 16b), the MT places ''atnah'' after "Sheol". Some modern translations follow this punctuation, seeing v. 16a as a case of "enjambment", a device, whereby a poetic thought spills over across two or more lines without a pause.<ref>Raabe 1990, 81.</ref> For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me" (NASB; cf. NIV; NET; ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; WYC; Luther 2017; NGÜ; ELB; EÜ; RVR95; NVI; BTX4; DHH; NBS; S21; PDV; BDS; NVSR; NRT; RST; UKR; BULG; etc.).
Some modern translations group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the first line/clause. For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me" (NASB; cf. NIV; NET; ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; WYC; Luther 2017; NGÜ; ELB; EÜ; RVR95; NVI; BTX4; DHH; NBS; S21; PDV; BDS; NVSR; NRT; RST; UKR; BULG; etc.).
<!--
seeing v. 16a as a case of "enjambment", a device, whereby a poetic thought spills over across two or more lines without a pause.<ref>Raabe 1990, 81.</ref>
-->
<argdown>
<argdown>
===
===
Line 42: Line 45:
         nodesep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
===
===
[Following the MT]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me" (NASB).#dispreferred
[Belongs with first clause]: The phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the first line/clause of the verse: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol" (NASB).#dispreferred
+ <MT's Punctuation>: The MT places atnah after "Sheol".#dispreferred
  + <Ancient Witnesses>: Some ancient witnesses support the reading of כִּי as temporal, which would support the MT's atnach after "Sheol."#dispreferred  
  + [Evidence 1]: אַךְ־אֱלֹהִ֗ים יִפְדֶּ֣ה נַ֭פְשִׁי מִֽיַּד־שְׁאֹ֑ול כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי סֶֽלָה׃.#dispreferred
   + [LXX]: “On the other hand, God will ransom my soul from Hades’ hand, when/όταν he receives me. Interlude on strings” (NETS).#dispreferred
+ <Enjambment>: MT uses a literary device, whereby a poetic thought spills over across two or more lines without a pause (Raabe 1990, 81 :M:).#dispreferred
   + [Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
  + <Ancient Witnesses>: Some ancient witnesses support the reading of כִּי as temporal, which would support the MT's atnah after "Sheol".#dispreferred  
   + [E.g., LXX]: The LXX uses όταν/when/whenever used to introduce conditional or temporal clauses. "On the other hand, God will ransom my soul from Hades’ hand, when he receives me. Interlude on strings" (NETS).#dispreferred
   + [E.g., Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
- <Ancient Versions>: Some ancient witnesses appear to support the MT.
  + [Peshitta]: ܐܠܗܐ ܢܦܪܩܝܗܿ ܠܢܦܫܝ ܘܡܢ ܐܝܕܐ ܕܫܝܘܠ ܢܣܩܢܝ܂/"God will save me; he will bring me up from the power of Sheol" (Taylor 2020). 
  + <External Evidence>: In the Hebrew Bible, the phrase "the power of Sheol" is used in conjunction with the verb "to redeem"/פדה. #dispreferred
  + <External Evidence>: In the Hebrew Bible, the phrase "the power of Sheol" is used in conjunction with the verb "to redeem"/פדה. #dispreferred
   + [Hos 13:14a]: "I will ransom them from the power of the grave/מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם..." #dispreferred
   + [Hos 13:14a]: "I will ransom them from the power of the grave/מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם..." #dispreferred
    <_<Hos 13:14>: Hos 13:14 places a prepositional phrase ("from Sheol" and "from death") before each predicate: מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם מִמָּ֖וֶת אֶגְאָלֵ֑ם
+ <The MT's Punctuation>: The MT places the major disjunctive accent atnach after "Sheol."#dispreferred
  + [Ps 49:16 (MT)]: אַךְ־אֱלֹהִ֗ים יִפְדֶּ֣ה נַ֭פְשִׁי מִֽיַּד־שְׁאֹ֑ול כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי סֶֽלָה׃.#dispreferred
- <Imbalance>: Grouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16a results in a imbalanced couplet.
  + [Ps 49:16 (NASB)]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me."
</argdown>
</argdown>
<!--
  + [Enjambment]: MT uses a literary device, whereby a poetic thought spills over across two or more lines without a pause (Raabe 1990, 81 :M:).#dispreferred
-->


===''Contra'' the MT (preferred)===
==="...Sheol" belongs with second clause (preferred)===
Although the MT places ''atnah'' after "Sheol" in v. 16b, some scholars and translations divide it after "my soul". For example, Dahood renders this verse as "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol Will he surely snatch me" (cf. NLT; GNT; CEV; NEB/REB; etc.).<ref>Dahood 1966, 301.</ref> He explains the significance of this punctuation and the link of  מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל to כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי as follows, "The  correct  stichometric  division  is  owed to  the  Ugaritic  specialists,  who  identified  in  ''ki  yiqqaheni'' the  emphasizing  particle  ''ki''  which  often  causes  the  postposition  of  the  verb.  Thus  in his  Ugaritic  Grammar  (Rome,  1940),  p.  54,  C.  H.  Gordon  listed  the present  passage  among  those  exhibiting  the  syntactic  phenomenon  placed in  such  clear  light  by,  e.g.,  UT,  62:1:14-15,  ''lktp  ‘nt  ktsth'',  'Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she  surely  puts  him.'"<ref>Dahood 1966, 301.</ref> The asseverative use of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew is well established<ref> See Muraoka 1985, 158–64. JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.</ref> and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.<ref>Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343, 521.</ref>   
Some scholars and translations group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the second line/clause. For example, Dahood renders this verse as "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me" (cf. NLT; GNT; CEV; NEB/REB; etc.).<ref>Dahood 1966, 301. He explains the significance of this punctuation and the link of  מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל to כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי as follows, "The  correct  stichometric  division  is  owed to  the  Ugaritic  specialists,  who  identified  in  ''ki  yiqqaheni'' the  emphasizing  particle  ''ki''  which  often  causes  the  postposition  of  the  verb.  Thus  in his  Ugaritic  Grammar  (Rome,  1940),  p.  54,  C.  H.  Gordon  listed  the present  passage  among  those  exhibiting  the  syntactic  phenomenon  placed in  such  clear  light  by,  e.g.,  UT,  62:1:14-15,  ''lktp  ‘nt  ktsth'',  'Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she  surely  puts  him.'" Ibid., 301.</ref> With such division, כִּי in v. 16b would be taken as having an asseverative role, which is well established in Biblical Hebrew<ref> See Muraoka 1985, 158–64; JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.</ref> and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.<ref>Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343, 521.</ref>   
<argdown>
<argdown>
===
===
Line 78: Line 84:
         nodesep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
===
===
[''Contra'' the MT]: But God will save my life and will take me from the grave (NCV).  
[Belongs with second clause]: The phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the second clause/line of the verse: "from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me" (Dahood 1966, 301 :C:).  
  - <Ancient Witnesses>: Give reasoning here.#dispreferred
  + <Ancient Versions>: Some ancient witnesses group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the second line of the verse.
   + [Evidence 1a]: Cite evidence here.#dispreferred
   + [LXX]: πλὴν ὁ θεὸς λυτρώσεται τὴν ψυχήν μου (line division) ἐκ χειρὸς ᾅδου, ὅταν λαμβάνῃ με. διάψαλμα/"On the other hand, God will ransom my soul (line division) from Hades’ hand, when he receives me. Interlude on strings" (NETS).
+ <LXX?>: Give reasoning here.
   + [Peshitta]: ܐܠܗܐ ܢܦܪܩܝܗܿ ܠܢܦܫܝ ܘܡܢ ܐܝܕܐ ܕܫܝܘܠ ܢܣܩܢܝ܂/"God will save me; he will bring me up from the power of Sheol" (Taylor 2020).  
   + [Evidence 1ab]: Cite evidence here.
  + <Biblical Usage of "To Take">: In the Hebrew Bible, in death-related contexts, the verb לקח represents a divinely-assisted transition to the afterlife.
  + <Biblical Usage of "To Take">: In the Hebrew Bible, the verb לקח represents divinely-assisted transition from this life to the afterlife.
   + [Biblical Usage]: Gen 5:24; 2 Kings 2:3, 5, 9 (cf. Sirach 13:15, 48:9); Ps 73:24.
   + [Evidence 1]: Gen v 24; II Kings ii 3, 5, 9; Sirach xiii 15, xlviii 9; as well as in Ps lxxiii 24.
  + <Ugaritic Usage>: In Ugaritic texts, the verb lqh appears in a similar death-related context (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + <Ugaritic Usage>: In Ugaritic texts, the verb lqh appears in a similar death-related context (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
   + [UT, 2059:21-22]: wklhm bd rb tmtt lqht/“And I snatched all of them from the hand(s) of the Master of Death (= Mot)” (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
   + [UT, 2059:21-22]: “And I snatched/lqht all of them from the hand(s) of the Master of Death (= Mot)” (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + <Placement of כי>: A similar syntax is found elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible (Krause 1984, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).  
  + <Syntax>: Grouping “…Sheol” with v. 16b results in a parallel structure in which both v. 16a and 16b begin with an emphatic element (i.e, clause initial particle אך in v. 16a and marked word order in v. 16b).
  + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB).  
+ <Balance>: Grouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16b results in a well-balanced couplet (8 syllables / 9 syllables; 4 words / 4 words).
</argdown>
</argdown>
<!--
+ <Asseverative Use of כִּי>: The particle may have an asseverative-emphatic use, "emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
  + [Asseverative כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + [Emphatic/Asseverative כִּי]: It is widely accepted for Ps 49:16 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:; Krause 1988, 480 :C:).
-->


==The Meaning and Function of כִּי==
==The Meaning and Function of כִּי==


==="Because"===
===Causal ("because")===
Some modern translations read the conjunction כִּי as "for" or "because", thus subordinating v. 16b to v. 16a. For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).  
Some modern translations read the conjunction כִּי as a causal conjunction ("for" or "because"). For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).  
<argdown>
<argdown>
===
===
Line 111: Line 122:
dot:
dot:
     graphVizSettings:  
     graphVizSettings:  
        rankdir: LR
         concentrate: true
         concentrate: true
         ranksep: 0.2
         ranksep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
===
===
[כִּי as "because"]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV).#dispreferred
[Causal]: The כִּי in v. 16 is a causal conjunction: "For He shall receive me" (NKJV).#dispreferred
  + <The Function of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle may be used with a meaning "because", introducing causal clauses (HALOT, 470 :L:) and makes sense contextually.#dispreferred
  + <Causal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי very often acts as a causal conjunction (HALOT, 470 :L:; Locatell 2017, 160-231).#dispreferred
   + [Ps 49:16]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).#dispreferred
  + [Causal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew]: E.g., Gen 31:31, 35; 47:4, 20; Deut 12:31. #dispreferred
- <Ancient Versions>: VSS do not support the reading of כִּי as because.#dispreferred
+ <Context>: Interpreting the כִּי as a causal conjunction makes sense contextually. #dispreferred
  + [E.g., LXX]: The LXX uses όταν/when/whenever used to introduce conditional or temporal clauses.#dispreferred
   + [Ps 49:16]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, for He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).#dispreferred
  + [E.g., Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
</argdown>
  - <Other Uses of כִּי>: The particle may have a asseverative-emphatic use; "it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context.” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
<!--
  - <Other Uses of כִּי>: The particle may have an asseverative-emphatic use, "emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
   + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
   + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + [Asseverative כִּי]: It is widely accepted for Ps 49:16 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:; Krause 1988, 480 :C:).
- <Asseverative כִּי>: It is widely accepted for Ps 49:16 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:; Krause 1988, 480 :C:).
  - <The Placement of כִּי>: For the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the predicate (e.g., Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13) (Muraoka 1985, 163 :M:).  
  - <The Placement of כִּי>: For the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the predicate (e.g., Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13) (Muraoka 1985, 163 :M:).  
   + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).
   + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).
  - <Syntax>: Clause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are also emphatic.
  - <Syntax>: Clause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are emphatic.
</argdown>
-->


==="When"===
===Temporal ("when")===
Some modern translations read כִּי as "when", as for example WYC, which renders v. 16 as "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).  
Some modern translations read כִּי as a temporal conjunction ("when"). For example, WYC renders v. 16 as "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).  
<argdown>
<argdown>
===
===
Line 154: Line 165:
         nodesep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
===
===
[כִּי as "when"]: "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (WYC).#dispreferred
[Temporal]: The כִּי in v. 16 is a temporal conjunction: "when he shall take me" (WYC).#dispreferred
  + <The Function of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle may be used temporally (JM §166o :G:) and makes sense contextually.#dispreferred
  + <Temporal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי may be used temporally (JM §166o :G:).#dispreferred
  + [Temporal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew]: E.g., 2 Sam 19:26; Jdg 1:28 (JM §166o :G:).#dispreferred
+ <Context>: The interpretation of כִּי as a temporal conjunction makes sense in the context.#dispreferred
   + [Ps 49:16]: "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).#dispreferred
   + [Ps 49:16]: "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).#dispreferred
+ <Ancient Versions>: Some of the ancient versions interpreted the כִּי as a temporal conjunction ("when").#dispreferred
  + [LXX]: "...when (ὅταν) he receives me" (NETS). #dispreferred
  + [Jerome (Hebr.)]: ...when (cum) he receives me." #dispreferred
</argdown>
<!--
  - <Other Uses of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle may have a asseverative-emphatic use; "it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context.” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
  - <Other Uses of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle may have a asseverative-emphatic use; "it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context.” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
   + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
   + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
   + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1984, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).
   + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1984, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).
+ <Ancient Versions>: Some versions support the reading of כִּי as "when".#dispreferred
-->
  + [E.g., LXX]: The LXX uses όταν/when/whenever used to introduce conditional or temporal clauses.#dispreferred
  + [E.g., Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
</argdown>


==="Surely" (preferred)===
===Asseverative ("surely") (preferred)===
Others take כִּי as the emphatic "surely", rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV; cf. NIV; NET; EÜ; S21; NFC; PDV; etc.). The asseverative כִּי has received much attention<ref> For bibliography, see Muraoka 1985, 158–64; JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.</ref> and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.<ref>Cf. Muraoka’s discussion on the asseverative use of this particle כִּי: “The etymologically deducible original demonstrative force of the particle ''ki'' was still alive alongside its later specializations, and this demonstrative function is the source of its occasional asseverative-emphatic use... It is used particularly when it appears in oath formulas, and closely related to that in the apodosis of conditional sentences. Beyond these uses, it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context.” Muraoka also notes the use of the asseverative כִּי in “a climatic construction” (e.g., Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13) (Muraoka, ''Emphatic Words'' 1985, 163). In all cases, emphasis is a consequence of contextual considerations (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 521).</ref>.  
Others take כִּי as the emphatic "surely", rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV; cf. NIV; NET; EÜ; S21; NFC; PDV; etc.). The asseverative כִּי has received much attention<ref> For bibliography, see Muraoka 1985, 158–64; JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.</ref> and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.<ref>Cf. Muraoka’s discussion on the asseverative use of this particle כִּי: “The etymologically deducible original demonstrative force of the particle ''ki'' was still alive alongside its later specializations, and this demonstrative function is the source of its occasional asseverative-emphatic use... It is used particularly when it appears in oath formulas, and closely related to that in the apodosis of conditional sentences. Beyond these uses, it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context” (Muraoka 1985, 163). In all cases, emphasis is a consequence of contextual considerations (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 521). But see Locatell who is cautious regarding this usage (2017, 275-276 and throughout). He, however, does not discuss Psalm 49.</ref>   
<argdown>
<argdown>
===
===
Line 189: Line 204:
         nodesep: 0.2
         nodesep: 0.2
===
===
[כִּי as "surely"]: "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV).
[Asseverative]: The כִּי in v. 16 is asseverative or emphatic: "surely...!" (e.g., NIRV).
  - <Ancient Versions>: VSS do not support the reading of כִּי as emphatic.#dispreferred
  + <The Function of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי may have an asseverative-emphatic use (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
   + [E.g., LXX]: The LXX uses όταν/when/whenever used to introduce conditional or temporal clauses.#dispreferred
   + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
   + [E.g., Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
+ <The Placement of כִּי>: For the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the verb (Muraoka 1985, 163 :M:).  
   + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 :C:; van der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:; see also Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13).
  + <Comparative Evidence>: In Ugaritic, this particle can also be used emphatically (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
  + <Comparative Evidence>: In Ugaritic, this particle can also be used emphatically (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
   + [UT,  62:1:14-15]: "Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she  surely  puts  him"/''lktp  ‘nt  ktsth'' (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
   + [UT,  62:1:14-15]: "Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she  surely  puts  him"/''lktp  ‘nt  ktsth'' (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
+ <The Function of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle may have a asseverative-emphatic use; "it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context.” (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
  + <Syntax>: Clause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are emphatic.
  + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + [Asseverative כִּי]: It is widely accepted for Ps 49:16 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:; Krause 1988, 480 :C:).
+ <The Placement of כִּי>: For the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the predicate (e.g., Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13) (Muraoka 1985, 163 :M:).
  + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 :C:; vad der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:).
  + <Syntax>: Clause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are also emphatic.
</argdown>
</argdown>


=Conclusion (B)=
=Conclusion (B)=


On balance, reading "from the power of Sheol" with v. 16b and כִּי as representing emphasis, e.g., "surely" is preferable. Such line division a.) makes most sense contextually; b.) has version support (''Syr''.);  c.) reflects the usage of לקח elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible (e.g., Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10) and in extrabiblical sources (...); and d.) is well presented among modern translations. The asseverative use of כִּי/"surely" has good support from a.) internal and external biblical evidence; and b.) context. At this juncture in the psalm, the psalmist seems to be indicating that he will be like one of those privileged individuals whom God "took" from life—e.g., Enoch and Elijah (Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10). "In light of broader OT usage, this 'taking' will be a rescuing from this-worldly trouble (cf. Ps. 18:16 [17]; Ezek. 36:24; 37:21), a rescuing from the threat of Sheol or from the way death can get its clutches on us in life (cf. 16:10; 18:5 [6]; 30:3 [4])."<ref>Goldingay 2007, 105-106. Cf. H.W. Wolff, who states: “The overcoming of death’s agony is not manifested in any elaborate hope of the beyond, but in the calm certainty that the communion with Yahweh cannot be ended by death, because of his faithfulness" (Wolff, ''Anthropology of the OT'' [1974], 109).</ref>
On balance, reading "from the power of Sheol" with v. 16b and כִּי as representing emphasis, e.g., "surely" is preferable. Such line division a.) makes most sense contextually; b.) has version support (''Syr''.);  c.) reflects the usage of לקח in death-related contexts in the Hebrew Bible (e.g., Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10) and in extrabiblical sources (UT, 2059:21-22); and d.) is well represented among modern translations. The asseverative use of כִּי/"surely" has good support from a.) internal and external biblical evidence; and b.) context. At this juncture in the psalm, the psalmist seems to be indicating that he will be like one of those privileged individuals whom God "took" from life—e.g., Enoch and Elijah (Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10). "In light of broader OT usage, this 'taking' will be a rescuing from this-worldly trouble (cf. Ps. 18:16 [17]; Ezek. 36:24; 37:21), a rescuing from the threat of Sheol or from the way death can get its clutches on us in life (cf. 16:10; 18:5 [6]; 30:3 [4])."<ref>Goldingay 2007, 105-106. Cf. H.W. Wolff, who states: “The overcoming of death’s agony is not manifested in any elaborate hope of the beyond, but in the calm certainty that the communion with Yahweh cannot be ended by death, because of his faithfulness" (Wolff, ''Anthropology of the OT'' [1974], 109).</ref>


=Research=
=Research=
Line 228: Line 239:


===Modern===
===Modern===
====Following the MT====
===="...Sheol" with first clause====
* But God will redeem me from the realm of the dead; he will surely take me to himself. (NIV)
* But God will redeem me from the realm of the dead; he will surely take me to himself. (NIV)
* But God will rescue my life from the power of Sheol; certainly he will pull me to safety. (Selah) (NET)
* But God will rescue my life from the power of Sheol; certainly he will pull me to safety. (Selah) (NET)
Line 243: Line 254:
* Pero Elohim redimirá mi alma de la mano del Seol, Porque me llevará consigo. Selah (BTX4)
* Pero Elohim redimirá mi alma de la mano del Seol, Porque me llevará consigo. Selah (BTX4)
* Pero Dios me salvará del poder de la muerte, pues me llevará con él. (DHH)  
* Pero Dios me salvará del poder de la muerte, pues me llevará con él. (DHH)  
* <ref>Footnote:...</ref>Mais Dieu me libérera du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (NBS)
* <ref>Footnote: "'''49:16.''' Cf. 30.4; 2S 4.9; Os 13.14.-''il me prendra'': 73.24n; Gn 5.24; 2R 2.3,5; Lc 16.22."</ref>Mais Dieu me libérera du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (NBS)
* Mais Dieu rachètera mon âme du séjour des morts, oui, il me prendra. – Pause. (S21)
* Mais Dieu rachètera mon âme du séjour des morts, oui, il me prendra. – Pause. (S21)
* Mais Dieu rachètera ma vie au pouvoir de la mort, oui, il me délivrera. (PDV)  
* Mais Dieu rachètera ma vie au pouvoir de la mort, oui, il me délivrera. (PDV)  
Line 252: Line 263:
* Та визволить Бог мою душу із влади шеолу, бо Він мене візьме! Села. (UKR)
* Та визволить Бог мою душу із влади шеолу, бо Він мене візьме! Села. (UKR)
* Но Бог ще изкупи душата ми от силата на преизподнята. Защото ще ме приеме. (Села) (BULG)
* Но Бог ще изкупи душата ми от силата на преизподнята. Защото ще ме приеме. (Села) (BULG)
TOB


====Contra the MT====
===="...Sheol" with second clause====
* But as for me, God will redeem my life. He will snatch me from the power of the grave. Interlude (NLT)
* But as for me, God will redeem my life. He will snatch me from the power of the grave. Interlude (NLT)
* But God will rescue me; he will save me from the power of death. (GNT)
* But God will rescue me; he will save me from the power of death. (GNT)

Latest revision as of 18:30, 24 January 2025

Introduction

The MT of Ps 49:16 reads as follows:[1]

אַךְ־אֱלֹהִ֗ים יִפְדֶּ֣ה נַ֭פְשִׁי מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי סֶֽלָה׃

This verse deals with the posthumous fate of the righteous speaker in contrast to the lot of the foolish, self-reliant rich, and is variously represented among modern translations. For example:

  • But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me. Selah (NASB)
  • But God will rescue me; he will save me from the power of death. (GNT)
  • But God will redeem me from the realm of the dead; he will surely take me to himself. (NIV)
  • God will ransom my soul from the hand of Sheol when he shall take me. Selah (JUB)

These translations indicate that there are two main difficulties in the interpretation of v. 16.

  1. One difficulty is related to the line division and syntax of v. 16. Should the prepositional phrase "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) be grouped with the preceding clause/line or with the following? The MT places the major disjunctive accent atnach on the word "Sheol," thereby grouping "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) with the preceding clause/line. Some modern translations follow this punctuation. For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, for He will receive me" (NASB). Other interpreters, however, group "from the power of Sheol" (מִיַּד שְׁאוֹל) with the following clause/line, rendering this verse as, "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me".[2] The latter reading indicates that the psalm presupposes the idea of "assumption" (cf. Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10).
  2. Another challenging point is the function of כִּי in v. 16b. Some read it as "for/because", thus subordinating v. 16b to v. 16a, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV). Some take it temporally, i.e., as "when" (e.g., JUB; WYC; etc.). Yet others take כִּי as the emphatic "surely," rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV).

Argument Maps

Line Division of v. 16

"...Sheol" belongs with first clause

Some modern translations group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the first line/clause. For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me" (NASB; cf. NIV; NET; ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; WYC; Luther 2017; NGÜ; ELB; EÜ; RVR95; NVI; BTX4; DHH; NBS; S21; PDV; BDS; NVSR; NRT; RST; UKR; BULG; etc.).


===
model:
    removeTagsFromText: true
    shortcodes:
      ":C:": {unicode: "🄲"}
      ":G:": {unicode: "🄶"}
      ":A:": {unicode: "🄰"}
      ":I:": {unicode: "🄸"}    
      ":L:": {unicode: "🄻"}
      ":D:": {unicode: "🄳"}    
      ":M:": {unicode: "🄼"}   
selection:
    excludeDisconnected: false
dot:
    graphVizSettings: 
        rankdir: LR
        concentrate: true
        ranksep: 0.2
        nodesep: 0.2
===
[Belongs with first clause]: The phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the first line/clause of the verse: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol" (NASB).#dispreferred
 + <Ancient Witnesses>: Some ancient witnesses support the reading of כִּי as temporal, which would support the MT's atnach after "Sheol."#dispreferred 
  + [LXX]: “On the other hand, God will ransom my soul from Hades’ hand, when/όταν he receives me. Interlude on strings” (NETS).#dispreferred
  + [Vulg.]: The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.#dispreferred
 + <External Evidence>: In the Hebrew Bible, the phrase "the power of Sheol" is used in conjunction with the verb "to redeem"/פדה. #dispreferred
  + [Hos 13:14a]: "I will ransom them from the power of the grave/מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם..." #dispreferred
    <_<Hos 13:14>: Hos 13:14 places a prepositional phrase ("from Sheol" and "from death") before each predicate: מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם מִמָּ֖וֶת אֶגְאָלֵ֑ם 
 + <The MT's Punctuation>: The MT places the major disjunctive accent atnach after "Sheol."#dispreferred
  + [Ps 49:16 (MT)]: אַךְ־אֱלֹהִ֗ים יִפְדֶּ֣ה נַ֭פְשִׁי מִֽיַּד־שְׁאֹ֑ול כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי סֶֽלָה׃.#dispreferred
 - <Imbalance>: Grouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16a results in a imbalanced couplet. 
  + [Ps 49:16 (NASB)]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me."


Argument Mapn0Belongs with first clauseThe phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the first line/clause of the verse: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol" (NASB).n1LXX“On the other hand, God will ransom my soul from Hades’ hand, when/όταν he receives me. Interlude on strings” (NETS).n6Ancient WitnessesSome ancient witnesses support the reading of כִּי as temporal, which would support the MT's atnach after "Sheol."n1->n6n2Vulg.The Vulg. uses cum/when/since/while.n2->n6n3Hos 13:14a"I will ransom them from the power of the grave/מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם..." n7External EvidenceIn the Hebrew Bible, the phrase "the power of Sheol" is used in conjunction with the verb "to redeem"/פדה. n3->n7n4Ps 49:16 (MT)אַךְ־אֱלֹהִ֗ים יִפְדֶּ֣ה נַ֭פְשִׁי מִֽיַּד־שְׁאֹ֑ול כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי סֶֽלָה׃.n9The MT's PunctuationThe MT places the major disjunctive accent atnach after "Sheol."n4->n9n5Ps 49:16 (NASB)"But God will redeem my soul from the power of Sheol, For He will receive me."n10ImbalanceGrouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16a results in a imbalanced couplet. n5->n10n6->n0n7->n0n8Hos 13:14Hos 13:14 places a prepositional phrase ("from Sheol" and "from death") before each predicate: מִיַּ֤ד שְׁאֹול֙ אֶפְדֵּ֔ם מִמָּ֖וֶת אֶגְאָלֵ֑ם n8->n3n9->n0n10->n0


"...Sheol" belongs with second clause (preferred)

Some scholars and translations group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the second line/clause. For example, Dahood renders this verse as "But God will ransom me, from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me" (cf. NLT; GNT; CEV; NEB/REB; etc.).[3] With such division, כִּי in v. 16b would be taken as having an asseverative role, which is well established in Biblical Hebrew[4] and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.[5]


===
model:
    removeTagsFromText: true
    shortcodes:
      ":C:": {unicode: "🄲"}
      ":G:": {unicode: "🄶"}
      ":A:": {unicode: "🄰"}
      ":I:": {unicode: "🄸"}    
      ":L:": {unicode: "🄻"}
      ":D:": {unicode: "🄳"}    
      ":M:": {unicode: "🄼"}   
selection:
    excludeDisconnected: false
dot:
    graphVizSettings: 
        rankdir: LR
        concentrate: true
        ranksep: 0.2
        nodesep: 0.2
===
[Belongs with second clause]: The phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the second clause/line of the verse: "from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me" (Dahood 1966, 301 :C:). 
 + <Ancient Versions>: Some ancient witnesses group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the second line of the verse.
  + [LXX]: πλὴν ὁ θεὸς λυτρώσεται τὴν ψυχήν μου (line division) ἐκ χειρὸς ᾅδου, ὅταν λαμβάνῃ με. διάψαλμα/"On the other hand, God will ransom my soul (line division) from Hades’ hand, when he receives me. Interlude on strings" (NETS).
  + [Peshitta]: ܐܠܗܐ ܢܦܪܩܝܗܿ ܠܢܦܫܝ ܘܡܢ ܐܝܕܐ ܕܫܝܘܠ ܢܣܩܢܝ܂/"God will save me; he will bring me up from the power of Sheol" (Taylor 2020).   
 + <Biblical Usage of "To Take">: In the Hebrew Bible, in death-related contexts, the verb לקח represents a divinely-assisted transition to the afterlife.
  + [Biblical Usage]: Gen 5:24; 2 Kings 2:3, 5, 9 (cf. Sirach 13:15, 48:9); Ps 73:24.
 + <Ugaritic Usage>: In Ugaritic texts, the verb lqh appears in a similar death-related context (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
  + [UT, 2059:21-22]: “And I snatched/lqht all of them from the hand(s) of the Master of Death (= Mot)” (Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
 + <Syntax>: Grouping “…Sheol” with v. 16b results in a parallel structure in which both v. 16a and 16b begin with an emphatic element (i.e, clause initial particle אך in v. 16a and marked word order in v. 16b).
 + <Balance>: Grouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16b results in a well-balanced couplet (8 syllables / 9 syllables; 4 words / 4 words).


Argument Mapn0Belongs with second clauseThe phrase "from the power of Sheol" belongs with the second clause/line of the verse: "from the power of Sheol will he surely snatch me" (Dahood 1966, 301 🄲). n1LXXπλὴν ὁ θεὸς λυτρώσεται τὴν ψυχήν μου (line division) ἐκ χειρὸς ᾅδου, ὅταν λαμβάνῃ με. διάψαλμα/"On the other hand, God will ransom my soul (line division) from Hades’ hand, when he receives me. Interlude on strings" (NETS).n5Ancient VersionsSome ancient witnesses group the phrase "from the power of Sheol" with the second line of the verse.n1->n5n2Peshittaܐܠܗܐ ܢܦܪܩܝܗܿ ܠܢܦܫܝ ܘܡܢ ܐܝܕܐ ܕܫܝܘܠ ܢܣܩܢܝ܂/"God will save me; he will bring me up from the power of Sheol" (Taylor 2020). n2->n5n3Biblical UsageGen 5:24; 2 Kings 2:3, 5, 9 (cf. Sirach 13:15, 48:9); Ps 73:24.n6Biblical Usage of "To Take"In the Hebrew Bible, in death-related contexts, the verb לקח represents a divinely-assisted transition to the afterlife.n3->n6n4UT, 2059:21-22“And I snatched/lqht all of them from the hand(s) of the Master of Death (= Mot)” (Dahood 1966, 301-302 🄲).n7Ugaritic UsageIn Ugaritic texts, the verb lqh appears in a similar death-related context (Dahood 1966, 301-302 🄲).n4->n7n5->n0n6->n0n7->n0n8SyntaxGrouping “…Sheol” with v. 16b results in a parallel structure in which both v. 16a and 16b begin with an emphatic element (i.e, clause initial particle אך in v. 16a and marked word order in v. 16b).n8->n0n9BalanceGrouping מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל with v. 16b results in a well-balanced couplet (8 syllables / 9 syllables; 4 words / 4 words).n9->n0


The Meaning and Function of כִּי

Causal ("because")

Some modern translations read the conjunction כִּי as a causal conjunction ("for" or "because"). For example, "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, For He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).


===
model:
    removeTagsFromText: true
    shortcodes:
      ":C:": {unicode: "🄲"}
      ":G:": {unicode: "🄶"}
      ":A:": {unicode: "🄰"}
      ":I:": {unicode: "🄸"}    
      ":L:": {unicode: "🄻"}
      ":D:": {unicode: "🄳"}    
      ":M:": {unicode: "🄼"}   
selection:
    excludeDisconnected: false
dot:
    graphVizSettings: 
        concentrate: true
        ranksep: 0.2
        nodesep: 0.2
===
[Causal]: The כִּי in v. 16 is a causal conjunction: "For He shall receive me" (NKJV).#dispreferred
 + <Causal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי very often acts as a causal conjunction (HALOT, 470 :L:; Locatell 2017, 160-231).#dispreferred
  + [Causal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew]: E.g., Gen 31:31, 35; 47:4, 20; Deut 12:31. #dispreferred
 + <Context>: Interpreting the כִּי as a causal conjunction makes sense contextually. #dispreferred
  + [Ps 49:16]: "But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, for He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).#dispreferred


Argument Mapn0CausalThe כִּי in v. 16 is a causal conjunction: "For He shall receive me" (NKJV).n1Causal כִּי in Biblical HebrewE.g., Gen 31:31, 35; 47:4, 20; Deut 12:31. n3Causal כִּי in Biblical HebrewThe particle כִּי very often acts as a causal conjunction (HALOT, 470 🄻; Locatell 2017, 160-231).n1->n3n2Ps 49:16"But God will redeem my soul from the power of the grave, for He shall receive me" (NKJV; cf. ESV; JPS 1985; NRSV; RVR95; BTX4; NBS; BDS; UKR; BULG; etc.).n4ContextInterpreting the כִּי as a causal conjunction makes sense contextually. n2->n4n3->n0n4->n0


Temporal ("when")

Some modern translations read כִּי as a temporal conjunction ("when"). For example, WYC renders v. 16 as "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).


===
model:
    removeTagsFromText: true
    shortcodes:
      ":C:": {unicode: "🄲"}
      ":G:": {unicode: "🄶"}
      ":A:": {unicode: "🄰"}
      ":I:": {unicode: "🄸"}    
      ":L:": {unicode: "🄻"}
      ":D:": {unicode: "🄳"}    
      ":M:": {unicode: "🄼"}   
selection:
    excludeDisconnected: false
dot:
    graphVizSettings: 
        rankdir: LR
        concentrate: true
        ranksep: 0.2
        nodesep: 0.2
===
[Temporal]: The כִּי in v. 16 is a temporal conjunction: "when he shall take me" (WYC).#dispreferred
 + <Temporal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי may be used temporally (JM §166o :G:).#dispreferred
  + [Temporal כִּי in Biblical Hebrew]: E.g., 2 Sam 19:26; Jdg 1:28 (JM §166o :G:).#dispreferred
 + <Context>: The interpretation of כִּי as a temporal conjunction makes sense in the context.#dispreferred
  + [Ps 49:16]: "Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).#dispreferred
 + <Ancient Versions>: Some of the ancient versions interpreted the כִּי as a temporal conjunction ("when").#dispreferred
  + [LXX]: "...when (ὅταν) he receives me" (NETS). #dispreferred
  + [Jerome (Hebr.)]: ...when (cum) he receives me." #dispreferred


Argument Mapn0TemporalThe כִּי in v. 16 is a temporal conjunction: "when he shall take me" (WYC).n1Temporal כִּי in Biblical HebrewE.g., 2 Sam 19:26; Jdg 1:28 (JM §166o 🄶).n5Temporal כִּי in Biblical HebrewThe particle כִּי may be used temporally (JM §166o 🄶).n1->n5n2Ps 49:16"Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me" (cf. JUB; NRT; RST; etc.).n6ContextThe interpretation of כִּי as a temporal conjunction makes sense in the context.n2->n6n3LXX"...when (ὅταν) he receives me" (NETS). n7Ancient VersionsSome of the ancient versions interpreted the כִּי as a temporal conjunction ("when").n3->n7n4Jerome (Hebr.)...when (cum) he receives me." n4->n7n5->n0n6->n0n7->n0


Asseverative ("surely") (preferred)

Others take כִּי as the emphatic "surely", rendering the verse as, "But God will save me from the place of the dead. He will certainly take me to himself" (NIRV; cf. NIV; NET; EÜ; S21; NFC; PDV; etc.). The asseverative כִּי has received much attention[6] and is widely accepted for Ps 49:16.[7]


===
model:
    removeTagsFromText: true
    shortcodes:
      ":C:": {unicode: "🄲"}
      ":G:": {unicode: "🄶"}
      ":A:": {unicode: "🄰"}
      ":I:": {unicode: "🄸"}    
      ":L:": {unicode: "🄻"}
      ":D:": {unicode: "🄳"}    
      ":M:": {unicode: "🄼"}   
selection:
    excludeDisconnected: false
dot:
    graphVizSettings: 
        rankdir: LR
        concentrate: true
        ranksep: 0.2
        nodesep: 0.2
===
[Asseverative]: The כִּי in v. 16 is asseverative or emphatic: "surely...!" (e.g., NIRV).
 + <The Function of כִּי in Biblical Hebrew>: The particle כִּי may have an asseverative-emphatic use (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 :M:; JM §164, 165a, e :G:; IBHS §39.3.4e :G:).
  + [Asseverative Use of כִּי]: Gen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19;
Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 :M:; Muilenburg 1961, 143 :A:; Dahood 1966, 301-302 :C:).
 + <The Placement of כִּי>: For the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the verb (Muraoka 1985, 163 :M:). 
  + [Ps 128:2a]: "You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 :C:; van der Lugt 2007, 70 :M:; see also Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13).
 + <Comparative Evidence>: In Ugaritic, this particle can also be used emphatically (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
  + [UT,  62:1:14-15]: "Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she  surely  puts  him"/''lktp  ‘nt  ktsth'' (Gordon 1940, 54 :G:).
 + <Syntax>: Clause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are emphatic.


Argument Mapn0AsseverativeThe כִּי in v. 16 is asseverative or emphatic: "surely...!" (e.g., NIRV).n1Asseverative Use of כִּיGen 22:17; Deut 2:7; 1 Sam 26:16; Isa 1:27, 29–30; 7:15–16; Jer 22:5, 24; 31:18–19; Amos 4:2; 77:12; Lam 3:22 (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343 🄼; Muilenburg 1961, 143 🄰; Dahood 1966, 301-302 🄲).n4The Function of כִּי in Biblical HebrewThe particle כִּי may have an asseverative-emphatic use (Muraoka 1985, 158–64 🄼; JM §164, 165a, e 🄶; IBHS §39.3.4e 🄶).n1->n4n2Ps 128:2a"You will surely eat what your hands have worked for/יְגִ֣יעַ כַּ֭פֶּיךָ כִּ֣י תֹאכֵ֑ל..." (HCSB; cf. CSB; Krause 1988, 480 🄲; van der Lugt 2007, 70 🄼; see also Ps 77:12; Isa 32:13).n5The Placement of כִּיFor the emphasizing purpose, in poetic texts, the particle can be directly fixed to the verb (Muraoka 1985, 163 🄼). n2->n5n3UT,  62:1:14-15"Upon  the shoulders  of  Anath  she surely  puts  him"/''lktp  ‘nt ktsth'' (Gordon 1940, 54 🄶).n6Comparative EvidenceIn Ugaritic, this particle can also be used emphatically (Gordon 1940, 54 🄶).n3->n6n4->n0n5->n0n6->n0n7SyntaxClause initial אַךְ in v. 16a and מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל in v. 16b are emphatic.n7->n0


Conclusion (B)

On balance, reading "from the power of Sheol" with v. 16b and כִּי as representing emphasis, e.g., "surely" is preferable. Such line division a.) makes most sense contextually; b.) has version support (Syr.); c.) reflects the usage of לקח in death-related contexts in the Hebrew Bible (e.g., Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10) and in extrabiblical sources (UT, 2059:21-22); and d.) is well represented among modern translations. The asseverative use of כִּי/"surely" has good support from a.) internal and external biblical evidence; and b.) context. At this juncture in the psalm, the psalmist seems to be indicating that he will be like one of those privileged individuals whom God "took" from life—e.g., Enoch and Elijah (Gen 5:24; 2 Kgs 2:3, 5, 9, 10). "In light of broader OT usage, this 'taking' will be a rescuing from this-worldly trouble (cf. Ps. 18:16 [17]; Ezek. 36:24; 37:21), a rescuing from the threat of Sheol or from the way death can get its clutches on us in life (cf. 16:10; 18:5 [6]; 30:3 [4])."[8]

Research

Translations

Ancient

  • LXX
    • πλὴν ὁ θεὸς λυτρώσεται τὴν ψυχήν μου ἐκ χειρὸς ᾅδου, ὅταν λαμβάνῃ με. διάψαλμα[9]
      • On the other hand, God will ransom my soul from Hades’ hand, when he receives me. Interlude on strings. (NETS)
  • Peshitta
    • ܐܠܗܐ ܢܦܪܩܝܗܿ ܠܢܦܫܝ ܘܡܢ ܐܝܕܐ ܕܫܝܘܠ ܢܣܩܢܝ܂[10]
      • God will save me[11]; he will bring me up from the power[12] of Sheol.[13]
  • Jerome (Iuxta LXX)
    • verumtamen Deus redimet animam meam de manu inferi cum acceperit me DIAPSALMA[14]
  • Jerome (Iuxta Hebr)
    • verumtamen Deus redimet animam meam de manu inferi cum adsumpserit me SEMPER[15]
  • Targum
    • אמר דוד ברוח נבואה ברם אלהא יפרוק נפשי מן דין גהנם ארום ילפינני אוריתיה לעלמין \/ודברינני לחולקיה לעלמא דאתי#1#/׃ [16]
      • David said through the spirit of prophecy[17] “But God will redeem[18] my soul from the judgment of Gehenna,[19] for he will teach me his Law.” For ever.[20]

Modern

"...Sheol" with first clause

  • But God will redeem me from the realm of the dead; he will surely take me to himself. (NIV)
  • But God will rescue my life from the power of Sheol; certainly he will pull me to safety. (Selah) (NET)
  • But God will ransom my soul from the power of Sheol, for he will receive me. Selah (ESV)
  • But God will redeem my life from the clutches of Sheol, for He will take me. Selah (JPS 1985)
  • But God will ransom my soul from the power of Sheol, for he will receive me. Selah (NRSV)
  • Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me.[21] (WYC)
  • Aber Gott wird mich erlösen aus des Todes Gewalt; denn er nimmt mich auf. Sela (Luther 2017)
  • Mich aber wird Gott erlösen und den Klauen des Todes entreißen, er wird mich zu sich holen und bei sich aufnehmen.[22] (NGÜ)
  • Gott aber wird mein Leben [23] erlösen von der Gewalt des Scheols; denn er wird mich aufnehmen[24]. (ELB)
  • Doch Gott wird mich auslösen aus der Gewalt der Unterwelt, ja, er nimmt mich auf. [Sela] (EÜ)
  • Pero Dios redimirá mi vida del poder del seol, porque él me tomará consigo. Selah (RVR95)
  • Pero Dios me rescatará de las garras de la muerte[25] y con él me llevará. Selah (NVI)
  • Pero Elohim redimirá mi alma de la mano del Seol, Porque me llevará consigo. Selah (BTX4)
  • Pero Dios me salvará del poder de la muerte, pues me llevará con él. (DHH)
  • [26]Mais Dieu me libérera du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (NBS)
  • Mais Dieu rachètera mon âme du séjour des morts, oui, il me prendra. – Pause. (S21)
  • Mais Dieu rachètera ma vie au pouvoir de la mort, oui, il me délivrera. (PDV)
  • Mais Dieu me délivrera ╵du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (BDS)
  • Mais Dieu libérera mon âme du séjour des morts, Car il me prendra[27]. Pause. (NVSR)
  • Но мою жизнь[28] искупит Бог от власти мира мертвых, когда примет меня к Себе. Пауза (NRT)
  • Но Бог избавит душу мою от власти преисподней, когда примет меня. (RST)
  • Та визволить Бог мою душу із влади шеолу, бо Він мене візьме! Села. (UKR)
  • Но Бог ще изкупи душата ми от силата на преизподнята. Защото ще ме приеме. (Села) (BULG)

"...Sheol" with second clause

  • But as for me, God will redeem my life. He will snatch me from the power of the grave. Interlude (NLT)
  • But God will rescue me; he will save me from the power of death. (GNT)
  • But God will rescue me from the power of death. (CEV)
  • But God will ransom my life, he will take me from the power of Sheol. (NEB)
  • But God will ransom my life and take me from the power of Sheol. [Selah (REB)
  • (But God shall redeem my soul; and he shall take me away from the power of Sheol, or the power of death. (WYC)
  • Ich bin gewiss: Gott wird mich erlösen, er wird mich den Klauen des Todes entreißen. (HFA)
  • Mein Leben aber – Gott selbst kauft es frei; aus den Krallen des Todes reißt er mich heraus! (GNB)
  • Gott aber wird mein Leben loskaufen, aus der Gewalt des Totenreichs nimmt er mich auf. Sela (ZÜR)
  • Mais Dieu me délivrera ! Oui, il m'arrache aux griffes de la mort ! Pause (NFC)

"Because"

  • But God will ransom my soul from the power of Sheol, for he will receive me. Selah (ESV)
  • But God will redeem my life from the clutches of Sheol, for He will take me. Selah (JPS 1985)
  • But God will ransom my soul from the power of Sheol, for he will receive me. Selah (NRSV)
  • Pero Dios redimirá mi vida del poder del seol, porque él me tomará consigo. Selah (RVR95)
  • Pero Elohim redimirá mi alma de la mano del Seol, Porque me llevará consigo. Selah (BTX4)
  • Mais Dieu me libérera du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (NBS)
  • Mais Dieu me délivrera ╵du séjour des morts, car il me prendra. Pause (BDS)
  • Та визволить Бог мою душу із влади шеолу, бо Він мене візьме! Села. (UKR)
  • Но Бог ще изкупи душата ми от силата на преизподнята. Защото ще ме приеме. (Села) (BULG)

"When"

  • Surely God will ransom my soul from the hand of Sheol when he shall take me. Selah. (JUB)
  • Nevertheless God shall again-buy my soul from the power of hell; when he shall take me.[29] (WYC)
  • Но мою жизнь[30] искупит Бог от власти мира мертвых, когда примет меня к Себе. Пауза (NRT)
  • Но Бог избавит душу мою от власти преисподней, когда примет меня. (RST)

"Surely"

  • But God will redeem me from the realm of the dead; he will surely take me to himself. (NIV)
  • But God will rescue my life from the power of Sheol; certainly he will pull me to safety. (Selah) (NET)
  • Doch Gott wird mich auslösen aus der Gewalt der Unterwelt, ja, er nimmt mich auf. [Sela] (EÜ)
  • Mais Dieu rachètera mon âme du séjour des morts, oui, il me prendra. – Pause. (S21)
  • Mais Dieu me délivrera ! Oui, il m'arrache aux griffes de la mort ! Pause (NFC)
  • Mais Dieu rachètera ma vie au pouvoir de la mort, oui, il me délivrera. (PDV)

Secondary Literature

Barthélemy, Dominique. 2005. Critique Textuelle de l’Ancien Testament. vol. 4: Psaumes. Fribourg, Switzerland: Academic Press.
Briggs, Charles Augustus and Emilie Grace Briggs. 1906. A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Psalms. vol. 2. ICC. Edinburgh: T&T Clark.
Clifford, Richard. 2002. Psalm 1-72. Abingdon Old Testament commentaries Nashville, TN: Abington Press.
Craigie, Peter C., and Marvin E. Tate. 1983. 2nd ed. Psalms 1–50. vol. 19. WBC. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.
Dahood, Mitchell. 1966. Psalms. Vol. 1. Anchor Bible Commentary. New York: Doubleday.
DeClaissé-Walford, Nancy, Rolf A. Jacobson, and Beth LaNeel Tanner. 2014. The Book of Psalms. NICOT. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
Delitzsch, Franz. 1883. Biblical Commentary on the Psalms. vol. 1. Translated by Eaton David. New York, NY: Funk and Wagnalls.
Dobbs-Allsopp, F. W. 2015. On Biblical Poetry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ewald, Heinrich. 1866. Die Dichter des Alten Bundes. Göttingen : Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
Fohrer, G. 1993. Psalmen. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Goldingay, John. 2007. Psalms 42–89. vol. 2. BCOT. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic.
Goulder, Michael D. 1982. The Psalms of the Sons of Korah. Sheffield: JSOT Press.
Gross, H. 1972. “Self-oder Fremderlösung.” Pages 65–70 in Wort, Lied und Gottesspruch: Beiträge zu Psalmen und Propheten.ed. J. Schreiner. (J. Ziegler FS). Würzburg: Echter.
Hengstenberg, Ernst Wilhelm. 1863. Commentary on the Psalms. vol. 2. Edinburgh: T&T Clark.
Hitzig, Ferdinand. 1863-1865. Die Psalmen, 2 vols. Leipzig: C.F. Winter.
Kissane, Edward. 1953. The Book of Psalms. vol. 1, Westminster, MD: The Newman Press.
Koehler, Ludwig, Walter Baumgartner, and Johann J. Stamm. 2001. The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament. 2 vols. Translated and edited under the supervision of Mervyn E. J. Richardson. Leiden: Brill.
Kraus, Hans-Joachim. 1972. Psalmen 1–63. BKT XV/1. Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag.
Muraoka, J. 1985. Emphatic Words and Structures in Biblical Hebrew. Leiden: Brill.
Sundermeier, Th. 1993. “Erlösung oder Versöhnung: Religionsgeschichtliche Anstöße.” EvT 53: 124-146.
Taylor, Richard A. trans., 2020. The Syriac Peshitta Bible with English Translation: Psalms. ed. by George A. Kiraz and Joseph Bali. The Antioch Bible/ṢṢurath Kthobh. Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias.
VanGemeren, Willem A. 1997. New International Dictionary of Old Testament Theology and Exegesis. 5 vols. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.
Volz, Paul. 1937. “Psalm 49.” ZAW 55: 235–64.
Weiser, Artur. 1962. The Psalms. OTL. Trans. by Herbert Hartwell. Philadelphia, PA: Westminster Press.
Witte, Markus. 2000. "‘Aber Gott wird meine Seele erlösen.’: Tod und Leben nach Psalm XLIX.” VT 50: 540–60.

References

49:16

  1. The Hebrew text comes from OSHB.
  2. Dahood 1966, 301.
  3. Dahood 1966, 301. He explains the significance of this punctuation and the link of מִֽיַּד־שְׁא֑וֹל to כִּ֖י יִקָּחֵ֣נִי as follows, "The correct stichometric division is owed to the Ugaritic specialists, who identified in ki yiqqaheni the emphasizing particle ki which often causes the postposition of the verb. Thus in his Ugaritic Grammar (Rome, 1940), p. 54, C. H. Gordon listed the present passage among those exhibiting the syntactic phenomenon placed in such clear light by, e.g., UT, 62:1:14-15, lktp ‘nt ktsth, 'Upon the shoulders of Anath she surely puts him.'" Ibid., 301.
  4. See Muraoka 1985, 158–64; JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.
  5. Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 343, 521.
  6. For bibliography, see Muraoka 1985, 158–64; JM §164, 165a, e; IBHS §39.3.4e.
  7. Cf. Muraoka’s discussion on the asseverative use of this particle כִּי: “The etymologically deducible original demonstrative force of the particle ki was still alive alongside its later specializations, and this demonstrative function is the source of its occasional asseverative-emphatic use... It is used particularly when it appears in oath formulas, and closely related to that in the apodosis of conditional sentences. Beyond these uses, it may be used for the emphasizing purpose when directly fixed to the predicate, and that almost exclusively in poetic context” (Muraoka 1985, 163). In all cases, emphasis is a consequence of contextual considerations (Dobbs-Allsopp 2015, 521). But see Locatell who is cautious regarding this usage (2017, 275-276 and throughout). He, however, does not discuss Psalm 49.
  8. Goldingay 2007, 105-106. Cf. H.W. Wolff, who states: “The overcoming of death’s agony is not manifested in any elaborate hope of the beyond, but in the calm certainty that the communion with Yahweh cannot be ended by death, because of his faithfulness" (Wolff, Anthropology of the OT [1974], 109).
  9. Rahlfs 1931.
  10. CAL.
  11. Translation note: "'me': lit. 'my soul'." (Taylor 2020, 191).
  12. Translation note: "'power': lit. 'hand'." (Taylor 2020, 191).
  13. Taylor 2020, 191.
  14. Footnote: "16 diapsalma om. RHWc." Weber-Gryson 5th edition.
  15. Footnote: "16 semper om. I". Weber-Gryson 5th edition.
  16. CAL.
  17. A note to see Introduction III.3 (Stec 2004, 103), which reads, "TgPss takes an interest in prophecy. In particular, the “spirit of prophecy” is a means of revelation associated with David (14:1; 49:16; 51:13,14; and probably also 22:27; 45:3), the sons of Korah (45:l[mss]; 46:1), Asaph (77:3; 79:1), and the prophets (68:34). Moreover, David is said to have sung a psalm in prophecy (18:1), to have spoken one in prophecy (103:1), and to have prophesied (49:17), and Solomon is said to have spoken in prophecy (72:1). Psalm 98 is described as a psalm of prophecy (98:1). The verb nb’, “prophesy” is found five times in TgPss (107:4, 10, 17, 23, 33), but not at all in the MT of the Psalms. Moreover, whereas the Hebrew noun nby’, “prophet” occurs only three times in the MT of the Psalter (51:2; 74:9; 105:15), its Aramaic equivalent is found an additional nine times in TgPss. As well as referring to prophets in general (18:17; 68:34; 74:9) or unnamed prophets (90:12; 110:7), TgPss also uses the word “prophet” in connection with particular prophets of the Bible: Moses (68:19; 90:1), Samuel (118:27), and Joel (107:33)" (Stec 2004, 5-6).
  18. "Crn, with B M Pm P 110; C P17 + yty, 'me.' This is perhaps an alternative translation to npšy, 'my soul,' which has entered the text" (Stec 2004, 103).
  19. "MT 'the power {lit. hand} of Sheol'” (Stec 2004, 103).
  20. "Following 'his Law,' and in place of 'For ever,' M P110 read 'and he will lead me to his portion in the world to come.'" (Stec 2004, 103).
  21. (But God shall redeem my soul; and he shall take me away from the power of Sheol, or the power of death.)
  22. Translation note: "Wörtlich: 'denn er wird mich wegnehmen' (od 'zu sich nehmen')."
  23. Translation note: "o. meine Seele."
  24. Translation note: "o. er wird mich ⟨dem Scheol⟩ entreißen."
  25. Translation note: "49:15 de la muerte. Lit. del Seol."
  26. Footnote: "49:16. Cf. 30.4; 2S 4.9; Os 13.14.-il me prendra: 73.24n; Gn 5.24; 2R 2.3,5; Lc 16.22."
  27. Translation note: "prendra. On pourrait traduire aussi: car il me prendra de la main du séjour des morts."
  28. Translation note: "Или: «душу»."
  29. (But God shall redeem my soul; and he shall take me away from the power of Sheol, or the power of death.)
  30. Translation note: "Или: «душу»."